Discover why Rarity Bay is a top choice for luxury lakeside living in East TN, offering scenic views, golf, and an unmatched lifestyle on Tellico Lake.
Nestled along the picturesque shores of Tellico Lake and surrounded by the Smoky Mountains, Rarity Bay is a premier gated community that has become one of East Tennessee’s most sought-after destinations for luxury living. Offering a unique blend of upscale amenities, natural beauty, and a vibrant social scene, Rarity Bay is more than just a neighborhood—it's a lifestyle. Whether you're looking for a forever home, a retirement retreat, or a seasonal getaway, Rarity Bay offers something truly special.
Location: The Best of Both Worlds
Rarity Bay is ideally situated in Vonore, TN, right between the charming town of Maryville and the scenic city of Tellico Plains. This places it just 45 minutes from downtown Knoxville and under 30 minutes to McGhee Tyson Airport. Residents enjoy the peace and tranquility of lakeside living without sacrificing access to shopping, dining, healthcare, and cultural activities.
Its location along Tellico Lake provides stunning water views, while the backdrop of the Smoky Mountains adds to the community's serene, postcard-worthy landscape. It’s no wonder this community continues to attract homebuyers from across the country, especially those looking to enjoy the natural beauty and slower pace of East Tennessee.
Real Estate in Rarity Bay
The real estate market in Rarity Bay offers a diverse range of properties to suit every buyer’s needs. Whether you’re looking for a luxurious lakefront estate, a custom-built home with mountain views, or a low-maintenance townhome close to amenities, there’s something for everyone.
Many homes in the community feature elegant, open-concept layouts, gourmet kitchens, spacious outdoor living areas, and high-end finishes. Lakefront properties often include private docks or access to community boat slips, making it easy for residents to enjoy boating and fishing just steps from their back door.
Home prices in Rarity Bay generally range from the mid $400s to well over $1 million, depending on location, size, and features. Despite the upscale nature of the community, many find the cost of living here to be surprisingly affordable compared to other luxury lakefront communities across the U.S.
Amenities Designed for Resort-Style Living
One of the major draws to Rarity Bay is its impressive list of amenities. This is a place where residents can enjoy a true resort-style lifestyle all year round. Key amenities include:
Golf Course
The Rarity Bay Golf & Country Club features an 18-hole championship golf course designed by D.J. DeVictor. With sweeping lake and mountain views, the course is both beautiful and challenging. It’s a favorite among avid golfers and social players alike.
Clubhouse & Dining
The recently renovated clubhouse is a social hub offering fine dining, a casual grill, and a variety of social events throughout the year. From themed dinners to wine tastings and live music, there’s always something happening.
Lake Access & Marina
Tellico Lake is one of the cleanest lakes in the Southeast, and Rarity Bay offers private access for boating, kayaking, paddleboarding, and fishing. The marina includes boat slips for residents and guests.
Equestrian Center
Rarity Bay is one of the few communities in the region that offers a private equestrian center, complete with stables, riding arenas, and trails. Whether you're a seasoned rider or new to horses, it’s a unique and tranquil experience.
Tennis & Pickleball
With tennis and pickleball courts available, residents stay active while enjoying the outdoors. Organized leagues and social games make it easy to meet neighbors and stay fit.
Fitness Center & Pools
A state-of-the-art fitness center and seasonal outdoor pool give residents additional options for wellness and relaxation.
Walking Trails & Parks
The community is laced with walking and biking trails that offer stunning views of the lake, woods, and mountains. Pocket parks and green spaces throughout Rarity Bay add to the peaceful, nature-rich atmosphere.
A Warm, Welcoming Community
Rarity Bay is more than just a beautiful place to live—it’s a community where people feel at home. With a strong focus on connection, there are clubs and social groups for almost every interest: gardening, golf, wine, books, travel, and more.
Many residents come from out of state, so it’s easy to make new friends and find common ground. The HOA and club leadership work hard to keep the community active and engaged, making Rarity Bay ideal for retirees and active adults who want to stay social and involved.
Rarity Bay for Retirees and Second Homeowners
Thanks to Tennessee’s tax-friendly policies (including no state income tax), and the relatively low property taxes in Monroe County, Rarity Bay has become an especially popular destination for retirees and snowbirds. Buyers from Florida, the Midwest, and the Northeast frequently relocate or purchase second homes here to take advantage of the mild climate and relaxed lifestyle.
Healthcare access is another important factor for retirees, and Rarity Bay residents benefit from proximity to high-quality medical facilities in Maryville, Loudon, and Knoxville.
Investment Potential
The combination of limited inventory, high demand, and desirable location means homes in Rarity Bay tend to hold their value well. Some properties are even used as vacation rentals or part-time residences, offering buyers a way to generate income when they’re not using the home.
As more people discover East Tennessee as a relocation hotspot, areas like Rarity Bay are only expected to grow in popularity—making now a great time to invest in this hidden gem.
Why Work with Allen Realty TN
At Allen Realty TN, we specialize in helping buyers and sellers navigate the unique real estate landscape of East Tennessee. Our team has extensive experience in luxury properties, lake homes, and gated communities like Rarity Bay.
We’re not just agents—we’re locals who understand the lifestyle, the market, and what makes this area so special. Whether you’re looking to schedule a tour, sell your current home, or just learn more about life in Rarity Bay, we’re here to help every step of the way.
Ready to Discover Rarity Bay?
If you're dreaming of lakefront mornings, golf course afternoons, and sunset views over the Smoky Mountains, Rarity Bay may be exactly what you’ve been looking for. With its perfect mix of luxury, nature, and community, it’s no surprise this neighborhood has become one of East Tennessee’s most desirable places to call home.
Explore available homes in Rarity Bay today by visiting AllenRealtyTN.com or contact us directly to schedule a showing and experience the lifestyle for yourself.
